Compare · 3 films

Avatar: Fire and Ash vs Spider Man Brand New Day vs Spider-Man: Brand New Day — Compare

Avatar: Fire and Ash 8.4/10

Spider Man Brand New Day 9.1/10

Spider-Man: Brand New Day 8.6/10

Add Film

AI Verdict

Comparing Avatar: Fire and Ash vs Spider Man Brand New Day vs Spider-Man: Brand New Day. Spider Man Brand New Day leads on expert rating.

Category Winners

Overall Winner Spider Man Brand New Day Overall

Top Rated Spider Man Brand New Day Overall

Biggest Hit Avatar: Fire and Ash

Most Awarded Avatar: Fire and Ash

Avatar: Fire and Ash

2025 195 min 4

8.4/10

Sci-Fi, Adventure, Fantasy

Winner

Spider Man Brand New Day

2026 145 min 3

9.1/10

Action, Adventure, Superhero

Winner

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

2026 144 min 72

8.6/10

Action, Adventure, Science Fiction

Visual Comparison

Ratings Radar

Runtime & Reviews

Release Timeline

Critic vs Audience

Specification	Avatar: Fire and Ash	Spider Man Brand New Day	Spider-Man: Brand New Day

Studio	20th Century Studios / Lightstorm Entertainment	Columbia Pictures / Marvel Studios / Pascal Pictures	Columbia Pictures
Franchise	Avatar	Spider-Man	Marvel Cinematic Universe
Release Date	2025-12-19	2026-07-31	2026-07-31
Runtime	195 min	145 min	144 min
Certification	PG-13	PG-13	PG-13
Genres	Sci-Fi, Adventure, Fantasy	Action, Adventure, Superhero, Science Fiction	Action, Adventure, Science Fiction, Superhero

Director(s)	—	—	—
Lead Cast	Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldaña, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Oona Chaplin	Tom Holland, Zendaya, Jacob Batalon, Sadie Sink, Jon Bernthal	Tom Holland, Zendaya, Jon Bernthal, Jacob Batalon, Sadie Sink

Critic Rating	8.4/10	9.1/10	8.6/10
Audience Rating	—	—	—
Review Count	0	0	0
Page Views	4	3	72

Budget	$400,000,000	—	$200,000,000
Worldwide Gross	$1,485,999,890	$95,000,000	—
Awards	2	0	1

Available On	Disney+, Apple TV, FindEdition	—	Theaters, Disney+, Apple TV, FindEdition

Pros	Exceptional visual effects; Expanded Pandora mythology; Strong emotional performances	Massive global Spider-Man search interest; Tom Holland returns as Peter Parker; Official story begins a fresh post-No Wa...	Mature street-level tone after No Way Home reset; Strong returning cast plus Bernthal and Ruffalo; Michael Giacchino ret...
Cons	Very long runtime; Dense franchise continuity	Several major character roles remain secret before release; Final box-office and audience reception are not yet availabl...	Not yet released — final box office and critical scores TBD; Sadie Sink role still undisclosed; Heavy fan expectations a...